I recommend the movie. At the very least, it has cool shiny fight scenes, but it also has a very positive portrayal of increased intelligence and rationality (“I knew what I had to do, and how to do it”), which avoids many of its pitfalls.
He has very little undeserved hubris—pretty much everything he claims to be able to do he can back up.
He acts fairly genre-savvy, and takes reasonable precautions like hiring bodyguards and investigating the source of his powers.
He avoids most intelligence stereotypes, becoming smarter actually makes him much more empathetic and cooler as a person. He gets his heads out of the clouds and starts actually accomplishing things.
Interestingly, many reviews chide the movie for allowing the protagonist to win at the end, with statements like “Working from Alan Glynn’s novel The Dark Fields, Burger and screenwriter Leslie Dixon are so content with keeping him on the fast track that they lose any sense of moral depth or consequence. It’s a small victory for flash in its eternal war with substance, but in this case, the flash is enough.”
A few comments:
Several parts of it were actually reminiscent of Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality, particularly the scene in which the girlfriend quickly scopes out everything around her that’s lethal.
All of the downsides of the drug were portrayed as purely technical problems, which can be surmounted with reasonable intelligence.
It’s worth noting that to the protagonist, these are only means to some (presumably world improving, but vaguely defined) end. His newfound status and power don’t seem to corrupt him, and he seems to get out of finance as soon as he’s happy with how much money he has.
Incidentally, according to a review of the book that I read, the book both begins and ends with the main character dying from withdrawal because his supply of the drug has run out and he is unable to get more… as he watches the President of the United States on television displaying what he recognizes as signs of being on the drug. So, in the book, the main character most definitely does not win at the end...
I recommend the movie. At the very least, it has cool shiny fight scenes, but it also has a very positive portrayal of increased intelligence and rationality (“I knew what I had to do, and how to do it”), which avoids many of its pitfalls.
He has very little undeserved hubris—pretty much everything he claims to be able to do he can back up.
He acts fairly genre-savvy, and takes reasonable precautions like hiring bodyguards and investigating the source of his powers.
He avoids most intelligence stereotypes, becoming smarter actually makes him much more empathetic and cooler as a person. He gets his heads out of the clouds and starts actually accomplishing things.
Interestingly, many reviews chide the movie for allowing the protagonist to win at the end, with statements like “Working from Alan Glynn’s novel The Dark Fields, Burger and screenwriter Leslie Dixon are so content with keeping him on the fast track that they lose any sense of moral depth or consequence. It’s a small victory for flash in its eternal war with substance, but in this case, the flash is enough.”
A few comments:
Several parts of it were actually reminiscent of Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality, particularly the scene in which the girlfriend quickly scopes out everything around her that’s lethal.
All of the downsides of the drug were portrayed as purely technical problems, which can be surmounted with reasonable intelligence.
It’s worth noting that to the protagonist, these are only means to some (presumably world improving, but vaguely defined) end. His newfound status and power don’t seem to corrupt him, and he seems to get out of finance as soon as he’s happy with how much money he has.
Incidentally, according to a review of the book that I read, the book both begins and ends with the main character dying from withdrawal because his supply of the drug has run out and he is unable to get more… as he watches the President of the United States on television displaying what he recognizes as signs of being on the drug. So, in the book, the main character most definitely does not win at the end...