Should I correct my posts after unambiguous mistakes are mentioned (specifically, mistakes in argumentation and the like, rather than grammatical errors, etc., which I would always correct), or should the original post be left alone for posterity? I figured that it would be better to correct it to save the time of future readers. In the particular instance that I’m talking about (I opted to correct, by the way), one of the commenters seemed to imply (very diplomatically, and I can’t be certain) that I was too concerned with editing the post for image-management-related purposes and that it would be better for me to simply move on and write more good posts as opposed to trying to improve that one. I also suspect that the answer is more nuanced than, “Always correct,” or, “Never correct.”
I think it’s up to you, but if you correct a post you should always make it explicit that you have done so and say what you did. Like Lumifer, I think it’s better to add a note at the end (or, in extreme cases, at the beginning) than just to overwrite the old content with the new; otherwise you risk making other people’s comments nonsensical.
I prefer writing postscriptums to drastic edits. If I was shown wrong, I usually concede in a separate comment rather than try to rewrite the original one.
Should I correct my posts after unambiguous mistakes are mentioned (specifically, mistakes in argumentation and the like, rather than grammatical errors, etc., which I would always correct), or should the original post be left alone for posterity? I figured that it would be better to correct it to save the time of future readers. In the particular instance that I’m talking about (I opted to correct, by the way), one of the commenters seemed to imply (very diplomatically, and I can’t be certain) that I was too concerned with editing the post for image-management-related purposes and that it would be better for me to simply move on and write more good posts as opposed to trying to improve that one. I also suspect that the answer is more nuanced than, “Always correct,” or, “Never correct.”
I think it’s up to you, but if you correct a post you should always make it explicit that you have done so and say what you did. Like Lumifer, I think it’s better to add a note at the end (or, in extreme cases, at the beginning) than just to overwrite the old content with the new; otherwise you risk making other people’s comments nonsensical.
I prefer writing postscriptums to drastic edits. If I was shown wrong, I usually concede in a separate comment rather than try to rewrite the original one.