This is a bit off-topic so I’m not going into any detail here, but you might check out this book by Max Boot, “Out of Order: Arrogance, Corruption, & Incompetence on the Bench”, a large proportion of the problems he wrote about arose from judges not being personally responible for their actions on the bench.
Also, more generally, I am a libertarian largely because I believe that everyone is totally and completely responsible for their own actions. Even if someone is holding a gun to your head, you decide what you do in response (and are responsible for letting yourself get in that position). Or if you are drunk or drugged, you are responsible for putting yourself in that position and therefore for what you do while that way.
I mean that people should bear some part of the forseeable costs of their actions.
I say “some part” because the actions of others also influence costs, and stress “foreseeable” because in any complex system things interact to such an extent that only very direct results can actually be attributed reliably to any one party.
Most attributions of “fault” in complex systems is scapegoating or motivated by interpersonal status games.
Can you clarify your disagreement with the doctrine of an unaccountable judiciary?
This is a bit off-topic so I’m not going into any detail here, but you might check out this book by Max Boot, “Out of Order: Arrogance, Corruption, & Incompetence on the Bench”, a large proportion of the problems he wrote about arose from judges not being personally responible for their actions on the bench.
Also, more generally, I am a libertarian largely because I believe that everyone is totally and completely responsible for their own actions. Even if someone is holding a gun to your head, you decide what you do in response (and are responsible for letting yourself get in that position). Or if you are drunk or drugged, you are responsible for putting yourself in that position and therefore for what you do while that way.
Could you explain in what sense you mean “personally responsible?”
I mean that people should bear some part of the forseeable costs of their actions. I say “some part” because the actions of others also influence costs, and stress “foreseeable” because in any complex system things interact to such an extent that only very direct results can actually be attributed reliably to any one party. Most attributions of “fault” in complex systems is scapegoating or motivated by interpersonal status games.