Hi Ruby! Thanks for the great feedback!! Sorry for the late reply, I’ve been working on the site!
So, we’re not doing just criticisms anymore- we’re ranking plans by Total Strength score—Total Vulnerabilities scores. Quite a few researchers have been posting their plans on the site! Going to do a full rebuild soon, to make the site look nicer and be even faster to work on. We’re also holding regular critique-a-thons. The last one went very well! We had 40+ submissions and produced what I think is really great work! We also made a Broad List of Vulnerabilities in the first two days! https://docs.google.com/document/d/1tCMrvJEueePNgb2_nOEUMc_UGce7TxKdqI5rOJ1G7C0/edit?usp=sharing
On not getting all of a plan’s details without talking to the person a lot- I think this is a vulnerability in communication. A serious plan, with the intention of actually solving the problem, should have the effort put into it to make it clear to a reader what it actually is, what problems it aims to solve, why it aims to solve them and how it seeks to do so. A failure to do so is silly for any serious strategy.
The good thing is, that if such a vulnerability is pointed out, on AI-Plans.com, the poster can see the vulnerability and iterate on it!
Hi Ruby! Thanks for the great feedback!! Sorry for the late reply, I’ve been working on the site!
So, we’re not doing just criticisms anymore- we’re ranking plans by Total Strength score—Total Vulnerabilities scores. Quite a few researchers have been posting their plans on the site!
Going to do a full rebuild soon, to make the site look nicer and be even faster to work on.
We’re also holding regular critique-a-thons. The last one went very well!
We had 40+ submissions and produced what I think is really great work!
We also made a Broad List of Vulnerabilities in the first two days! https://docs.google.com/document/d/1tCMrvJEueePNgb2_nOEUMc_UGce7TxKdqI5rOJ1G7C0/edit?usp=sharing
On not getting all of a plan’s details without talking to the person a lot- I think this is a vulnerability in communication.
A serious plan, with the intention of actually solving the problem, should have the effort put into it to make it clear to a reader what it actually is, what problems it aims to solve, why it aims to solve them and how it seeks to do so.
A failure to do so is silly for any serious strategy.
The good thing is, that if such a vulnerability is pointed out, on AI-Plans.com, the poster can see the vulnerability and iterate on it!