Copying my comment from 2023 version of this article
Soares’s comment which you link as a critique of guaranteed safe AI is almost certainly not a critique. It’s more of an overview/distillation.
In his comment, Soares actually explicitly says: 1) “Here’s a recent attempt of mine at a distillation of a fragment of this plan” and 2) “note: I’m simply attempting to regurgitate the idea here”.
It would maybe fit into the “overview” section, but not in the “critique” section.
Copying my comment from 2023 version of this article
Soares’s comment which you link as a critique of guaranteed safe AI is almost certainly not a critique. It’s more of an overview/distillation.
In his comment, Soares actually explicitly says: 1) “Here’s a recent attempt of mine at a distillation of a fragment of this plan” and 2) “note: I’m simply attempting to regurgitate the idea here”.
It would maybe fit into the “overview” section, but not in the “critique” section.