So, lessons learned? It’s probably a good idea to include such a paragraph since it’s so cheap and apparently isn’t at the expense of submissions in general.
Now that you’ve written this post up though, don’t you risk people wondering “are they actually going to do that, or are they just saying that to encourage me?”
Yes, but this could be said of any experiment ever which involves deception.
And besides, typically research ethics calls for deceived participants to be debriefed. Either the meta-paper will be written in which case no deception is involved and there was no reason not to post this writeup; or it won’t, in which case deception was involved and this writeup is ethically mandated. So either way, this writeup was worth doing.
Do you mean that this post to Less Wrong is the debriefing? I don’t think that posting to a blog, even one that the experimental subjects often read, is enough. What did the ethics committee say? :-)
I asked the committee in my head, and they said ‘We’re sure they read Discussion as much as you do. So good job—as a reward, you can go order yourself some mead!’ I feel sorry for all the other guys who don’t have as understanding an ethics committee as I do.
Now that you’ve written this post up though, don’t you risk people wondering “are they actually going to do that, or are they just saying that to encourage me?”
Yes, but this could be said of any experiment ever which involves deception.
And besides, typically research ethics calls for deceived participants to be debriefed. Either the meta-paper will be written in which case no deception is involved and there was no reason not to post this writeup; or it won’t, in which case deception was involved and this writeup is ethically mandated. So either way, this writeup was worth doing.
Do you mean that this post to Less Wrong is the debriefing? I don’t think that posting to a blog, even one that the experimental subjects often read, is enough. What did the ethics committee say? :-)
I asked the committee in my head, and they said ‘We’re sure they read Discussion as much as you do. So good job—as a reward, you can go order yourself some mead!’ I feel sorry for all the other guys who don’t have as understanding an ethics committee as I do.