Not necessarily. In high school politics, pure looks, physical form, and financial support from the parents, all of which are essentially unrelated to brain processing, account for a significant chunk.
Popular media reference: look at Jersey shore, which is essentially the high school politics turned up. Many of the actors used very simple strategies, such as Snooki wandering around drunk and saying funny things, or Ronnie essentially just doing plenty of steroids and getting into endless fights.
Other than making sure the robotics hardware looks good, an AI algorithm could be dramatically more compact than the example you gave by developing a “popularity maximizing” policy from the knowledge of many other robots in many other high schools. Most likely, Carl is using a deeply suboptimal policy, not having seen enough training examples in his maximum of 4 years of episodes. (unless he got held back a year). A close to optimal policy, even one with a small compute budget, should greatly outperform Carl.
and would be more popular
Not necessarily. In high school politics, pure looks, physical form, and financial support from the parents, all of which are essentially unrelated to brain processing, account for a significant chunk.
Popular media reference: look at Jersey shore, which is essentially the high school politics turned up. Many of the actors used very simple strategies, such as Snooki wandering around drunk and saying funny things, or Ronnie essentially just doing plenty of steroids and getting into endless fights.
Other than making sure the robotics hardware looks good, an AI algorithm could be dramatically more compact than the example you gave by developing a “popularity maximizing” policy from the knowledge of many other robots in many other high schools. Most likely, Carl is using a deeply suboptimal policy, not having seen enough training examples in his maximum of 4 years of episodes. (unless he got held back a year). A close to optimal policy, even one with a small compute budget, should greatly outperform Carl.