Since the calculator specifies “animal foods”, that may be reasonable. Hunted foods are a distinct argument, but when talking about animal products in the general sense, I think it’s safe to refer to the common case, which is a factory farm. An argument could be made that the lives of animals on factory farms have negative value to themselves. On the other hand, calculating suffering seems sort of silly since there’s no way to measure it or many of the other categories on the calculator. I think that website’s convincing but I’m not sure it proves anything or presents a real argument.
Since the calculator specifies “animal foods”, that may be reasonable. Hunted foods are a distinct argument, but when talking about animal products in the general sense, I think it’s safe to refer to the common case, which is a factory farm. An argument could be made that the lives of animals on factory farms have negative value to themselves. On the other hand, calculating suffering seems sort of silly since there’s no way to measure it or many of the other categories on the calculator. I think that website’s convincing but I’m not sure it proves anything or presents a real argument.