I expect that more than one of my brain modules are trying to judge between incompatible conclusions, and selectively giving attention to the inputs of the problem.
My thinking was similar to yours—it feels less like I’m applying scope insensitivity and more like I’m rounding the disutility of specks down due to their ubiquity, or their severity relative to torture, or the fact that the effects are so dispersed. If one situation goes unnoticed, lost in the background noise, while another irreparably damages someone’s mind, then that should have some impact on the utility function. My intuition tells me that this justifies rounding the impact of a speck down to zero, that the difference is a difference of kind, not of degree, that I should treat these as fundamentally different. At the same time, like Vincent, I’m inclined to assign non-zero disutility value to a speck.
One brain, two modules, two incompatible judgements. I’m willing to entertain the possibility that this is a bug. But I’m not ready yet to declare one module the victor.
I expect that more than one of my brain modules are trying to judge between incompatible conclusions, and selectively giving attention to the inputs of the problem.
My thinking was similar to yours—it feels less like I’m applying scope insensitivity and more like I’m rounding the disutility of specks down due to their ubiquity, or their severity relative to torture, or the fact that the effects are so dispersed. If one situation goes unnoticed, lost in the background noise, while another irreparably damages someone’s mind, then that should have some impact on the utility function. My intuition tells me that this justifies rounding the impact of a speck down to zero, that the difference is a difference of kind, not of degree, that I should treat these as fundamentally different. At the same time, like Vincent, I’m inclined to assign non-zero disutility value to a speck.
One brain, two modules, two incompatible judgements. I’m willing to entertain the possibility that this is a bug. But I’m not ready yet to declare one module the victor.