“Good” and “bad” only make sense in the context of (human) minds.
Ah yes, my mistake to (ab)use the term “objective” all this time.
So you do of course at least agree that there are such minds for which there is “good” and “bad”, as you just said.
Now, would you agree that one can generalize (or “abstract” if you prefer that term here) the concept of subjective good and bad across all imaginable minds that could possibly exist in reality, or not? I assume you will, you can talk about it after all.
Can we then not reason about the subjective good and bad for all these imaginable minds? And does this in turn not allow us to compare good and bad for any potential future subject sets as well?
Ah yes, my mistake to (ab)use the term “objective” all this time.
So you do of course at least agree that there are such minds for which there is “good” and “bad”, as you just said.
Now, would you agree that one can generalize (or “abstract” if you prefer that term here) the concept of subjective good and bad across all imaginable minds that could possibly exist in reality, or not? I assume you will, you can talk about it after all.
Can we then not reason about the subjective good and bad for all these imaginable minds? And does this in turn not allow us to compare good and bad for any potential future subject sets as well?