I predict that when your wife read “The Simple Truth” she was not acquainted with (or was not thinking about) the various theories of truth
that philosophers have come up with. I like it a lot, but
when I first read it I was able to see it as a defense of a
particular theory of truth and a critique of some other
ones.
Edit: In other words, I think “The Simple Truth”
appeals mainly to people who have read descriptions of the
other theories of truth and said to themselves, “People
actually believe that?!”
You’re correct. What I love about the Sequences in general is that it’s a colloquial, patient introduction to lots of new concepts. In theory, even somebody with no background in decision theories or quantum mechanics can actually learn these concepts from the Sequences. The Simple Truth is significantly different in tone and style from the majority of Sequence posts and the concepts which that post satirizes are not really introduced before the comedy begins.
If you go to http://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Sequences and choose the first option (1 Core Sequences), then choose the first listed subsequence (Map and Territory), the very first post is The Simple Truth. The second choice is What Do We Mean by Rationality? which really, really seems like it should be the first thing a newcomer reads.
I predict that when your wife read “The Simple Truth” she was not acquainted with (or was not thinking about) the various theories of truth that philosophers have come up with. I like it a lot, but when I first read it I was able to see it as a defense of a particular theory of truth and a critique of some other ones.
(In particular, it’s a defense of the correspondence theory, though see this thread.)
Edit: In other words, I think “The Simple Truth” appeals mainly to people who have read descriptions of the other theories of truth and said to themselves, “People actually believe that?!”
You’re correct. What I love about the Sequences in general is that it’s a colloquial, patient introduction to lots of new concepts. In theory, even somebody with no background in decision theories or quantum mechanics can actually learn these concepts from the Sequences. The Simple Truth is significantly different in tone and style from the majority of Sequence posts and the concepts which that post satirizes are not really introduced before the comedy begins.
If you go to http://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Sequences and choose the first option (1 Core Sequences), then choose the first listed subsequence (Map and Territory), the very first post is The Simple Truth. The second choice is What Do We Mean by Rationality? which really, really seems like it should be the first thing a newcomer reads.