Another consideration for orca intelligence; they dodge the fermi paradox by not having arms.
Assume the main driver of genetic selection for intelligence is the social arms-race. As soon as a species gets intelligent enough (see humans) from this arms-race they start using their intelligence for manipulating the environment, and start civilization. But orcas mostly lack the external organs for manipulating the enviroment, so they can keep social-arms-racing-boosting-intelligence way past the point of “criticality”.
This should be checkable, IE how long have orcas (or orca-forefathers) been socially-arms-racing? I tried asking claude to no avail, and I lack the domain knowledge to quickly look it up myself. Perhaps one could also check genetic change over time, perhaps social arms race is something you can see in this data? Do we know what this looks like in humans and orcas?
(warning: armchair evolutionary biology)
Another consideration for orca intelligence; they dodge the fermi paradox by not having arms.
Assume the main driver of genetic selection for intelligence is the social arms-race. As soon as a species gets intelligent enough (see humans) from this arms-race they start using their intelligence for manipulating the environment, and start civilization. But orcas mostly lack the external organs for manipulating the enviroment, so they can keep social-arms-racing-boosting-intelligence way past the point of “criticality”.
This should be checkable, IE how long have orcas (or orca-forefathers) been socially-arms-racing? I tried asking claude to no avail, and I lack the domain knowledge to quickly look it up myself. Perhaps one could also check genetic change over time, perhaps social arms race is something you can see in this data? Do we know what this looks like in humans and orcas?