So you’re testing if the answers will be consistent, rather than correct?
I think the goal is to see how well Holmesian reason works and how it fails.
The goal is to see what happens.
How can this show how well it works? There’s no correct answer, since the example is made up.
Well it won’t provide very much evidence, but, especially with a few more examples, there’s a chance we’ll learn something.
So you’re testing if the answers will be consistent, rather than correct?
I think the goal is to see how well Holmesian reason works and how it fails.
The goal is to see what happens.
How can this show how well it works? There’s no correct answer, since the example is made up.
Well it won’t provide very much evidence, but, especially with a few more examples, there’s a chance we’ll learn something.