Richard: If you are still reading here, would you generally agree with “athmwiji”? To me, his position seems reasonable while yours (bridging laws etc) does not, but both are non-materialist in some sense and I would like to know how you responded to his post in any event.
Eliezer: I assume that this whole bundle of threads is aimed at responding to claims like athmwiji’s, so I won’t ask for a response here unless my assumption is incorrect. My guess is that you think that you have a good counter, or at least a method for reaching a good counter, but if not then you really need one.
Richard: If you are still reading here, would you generally agree with “athmwiji”? To me, his position seems reasonable while yours (bridging laws etc) does not, but both are non-materialist in some sense and I would like to know how you responded to his post in any event.
Eliezer: I assume that this whole bundle of threads is aimed at responding to claims like athmwiji’s, so I won’t ask for a response here unless my assumption is incorrect. My guess is that you think that you have a good counter, or at least a method for reaching a good counter, but if not then you really need one.