Only if I would choose death given your probability distribution (or the only reason I wouldn’t is because of something like time discounting or not really imagining how bad it would be), and your probability distribution is more correct than mine.
So, if you discount time differently from me in a specific manner, it becomes mandatory for me (given the chance) to either condemn you to death or condemn you to eternal torture, and vice versa?
If a very long life followed by eternal torture is good for me but bad for you, I must condemn you to the torture and you must condemn me to death, rather than letting each of us decide for ourselves with full knowledge?
That’s exactly the opposite of what should happen; I should provide for you the option that you prefer you to have.
Only if I would choose death given your probability distribution (or the only reason I wouldn’t is because of something like time discounting or not really imagining how bad it would be), and your probability distribution is more correct than mine.
So, if you discount time differently from me in a specific manner, it becomes mandatory for me (given the chance) to either condemn you to death or condemn you to eternal torture, and vice versa?
If a very long life followed by eternal torture is good for me but bad for you, I must condemn you to the torture and you must condemn me to death, rather than letting each of us decide for ourselves with full knowledge?
That’s exactly the opposite of what should happen; I should provide for you the option that you prefer you to have.