Thanks for your reply. Reading the sentence “rationality is one of the most powerful tools we have to dissect and analyze [morality]” seemed to imply that you thought there were other “equally powerful” (powerful = reliably working) tools to arrive at true conclusions about morality.
As far as I’m concerned rationality is the whole superset, so I was curious about your take on it. And yes, your above options are surely not included in what I would consider to be “powerful tools to arrive at true conclusions”. Ultimately I think we don’t actually disagree about anything—just another “but does it really make a sound” pitfall.
Thanks for your reply. Reading the sentence “rationality is one of the most powerful tools we have to dissect and analyze [morality]” seemed to imply that you thought there were other “equally powerful” (powerful = reliably working) tools to arrive at true conclusions about morality.
As far as I’m concerned rationality is the whole superset, so I was curious about your take on it. And yes, your above options are surely not included in what I would consider to be “powerful tools to arrive at true conclusions”. Ultimately I think we don’t actually disagree about anything—just another “but does it really make a sound” pitfall.