The following comments are from the last LW thread:
(1) I’m not sure if you meant it as that, but it seems to me that there are two important truths I want to cover here:
There’s a big difference between a “somewhat good” and a “somewhat bad” state. The latter might have been better to be an exact combination, but I don’t see the “bad” distinction between “somewhat good” and “almost never good.”
This is not a big difference.
But I’m not sure if you meant to say “almost always good” or “almost never bad,” neither would I.
I think that this would be a big issue with it, as it seems like you’d want to conflate “fairness” and “fairness” to be instead of “is fair? Okay? We know that!
There’s a problem where I really don’t buy this.
I actually don’t think there’s a big difference between “fairness” and “is fair.” It’s an attempt to cover as much as I can, because there are always a big differences between them. If we don’t, the question that is posed is not “should I update?”, but rather “is fair.”
Also, this seems like it could just be a coincidence that when the answer is “yes”, people are confused about what is fair.
The following comments are from the last LW thread:
(1) I’m not sure if you meant it as that, but it seems to me that there are two important truths I want to cover here:
There’s a big difference between a “somewhat good” and a “somewhat bad” state. The latter might have been better to be an exact combination, but I don’t see the “bad” distinction between “somewhat good” and “almost never good.”
This is not a big difference.
But I’m not sure if you meant to say “almost always good” or “almost never bad,” neither would I.
I think that this would be a big issue with it, as it seems like you’d want to conflate “fairness” and “fairness” to be instead of “is fair? Okay? We know that!
There’s a problem where I really don’t buy this. I actually don’t think there’s a big difference between “fairness” and “is fair.” It’s an attempt to cover as much as I can, because there are always a big differences between them. If we don’t, the question that is posed is not “should I update?”, but rather “is fair.”
Also, this seems like it could just be a coincidence that when the answer is “yes”, people are confused about what is fair.