I apologize. I thought I had discharged the devil’s-advocacy-signaling obligation by ending my original post on the subject with a request to be proved wrong.
I agree that personal satisfaction with CEV isn’t a sufficient condition for it being safe. For that matter, having proposed and briefly defended this one alternative isn’t really sufficient for my personal satisfaction in either CEV’s adequacy or the lack of a better option. But we have to start somewhere, and if someone did come up with a better alternative to CEV, I’d want to make sure that it got fair consideration.
I apologize. I thought I had discharged the devil’s-advocacy-signaling obligation by ending my original post on the subject with a request to be proved wrong.
I agree that personal satisfaction with CEV isn’t a sufficient condition for it being safe. For that matter, having proposed and briefly defended this one alternative isn’t really sufficient for my personal satisfaction in either CEV’s adequacy or the lack of a better option. But we have to start somewhere, and if someone did come up with a better alternative to CEV, I’d want to make sure that it got fair consideration.