Yeah but doesn’t this expose an inconsistency in your view of quantum suicide? At least there’s some really counterintuitive things if you look at it that way—like, that you should refuse to acquire some data, or that if faced with “doom in ten months or doom now” you would prefer the “doom now”—I think any theory that acts so at odds with the rest of reason has to be doing something wrong.
Personally, I simply expect to never find myself in the situation where my doom is inevitable, and it’s paid off so far.
If I find myself in the doomed branch, I’ll say “yes this sucks for me, but I am merely a negligible fraction of the future that past-me was responsible for, so I still maintain that his decision was the right one”.
Yeah but doesn’t this expose an inconsistency in your view of quantum suicide? At least there’s some really counterintuitive things if you look at it that way—like, that you should refuse to acquire some data, or that if faced with “doom in ten months or doom now” you would prefer the “doom now”—I think any theory that acts so at odds with the rest of reason has to be doing something wrong.
Personally, I simply expect to never find myself in the situation where my doom is inevitable, and it’s paid off so far.
If I find myself in the doomed branch, I’ll say “yes this sucks for me, but I am merely a negligible fraction of the future that past-me was responsible for, so I still maintain that his decision was the right one”.