If someone disliked Will’s comment they could already downvote it.
Yes, but they couldn’t downvote my upvote, which is why I made a karma sink for them.
I repeat, if you are actually interested in rational discussion then you might want to consider explaining what I said that makes Will’s response appropriate.
Material implications are always true when their antecedent is false.
From others of your comments it’s clear that you’re a very intelligent person, so I promise I’d pay attention.
Flatterer.
I take it that Will’s remark and yours are intended to indicate some particularly egregious wrongness on my part
Yes, but they couldn’t downvote my upvote, which is why I made a karma sink for them.
Material implications are always true when their antecedent is false.
Flatterer.
Probably unwarranted.
EDIT: Unwarranted; see brother comment.