I agree this is an excellent post.
In fact, I just created an account and came out of lurking just to vote it up.
Yes, the example came out a little forced and unnecessarily convoluted, but the point made is extremely important.
To those who clamp down on the post on grounds of lack of formal rigour are missing the point entirely. You are so preoccupied with formulating your rationality in mathematically pleasing ways, applying it to matrix-magic and Knuth-arrow-quasi-infinity situations, that you are in danger of missing the real-life applications where just a modest bit of rationality will result in a substantial gain to yourself or to society.
I’m curious as to why this is being downvoted. (I already upvoted it from −1 to 0 once, but now it’s back to negatives.) Positive feedback should be encouraged.
Verbal comments have a much greater psychological effect than anonymous upvotes. (Especially when there seem to be a bunch of downvotes, meaning that most of the upvotes effectively become invisible.)
Excellent post, I will keep these ideas in mind in future arguments.
I agree this is an excellent post. In fact, I just created an account and came out of lurking just to vote it up. Yes, the example came out a little forced and unnecessarily convoluted, but the point made is extremely important. To those who clamp down on the post on grounds of lack of formal rigour are missing the point entirely. You are so preoccupied with formulating your rationality in mathematically pleasing ways, applying it to matrix-magic and Knuth-arrow-quasi-infinity situations, that you are in danger of missing the real-life applications where just a modest bit of rationality will result in a substantial gain to yourself or to society.
I’m curious as to why this is being downvoted. (I already upvoted it from −1 to 0 once, but now it’s back to negatives.) Positive feedback should be encouraged.
Run-on sentence? :) Redundant with the “Vote Up” button?
Verbal comments have a much greater psychological effect than anonymous upvotes. (Especially when there seem to be a bunch of downvotes, meaning that most of the upvotes effectively become invisible.)
Of course. I guess they may impose a cost on some readers, though.