Though evolution, as such, did encounter resistance, particularly from some religious groups, it was by no means the greatest of the difficulties the Darwinians faced. That difficulty stemmed from an idea that was more nearly Darwin’s own. All the well-known pre-Darwinian evolutionary theories—those of Lamarck, Chambers, Spencer, and the German Naturphilosophen—had taken evolution to be a goal-directed process.
The “idea” of man and of the contemporary flora and fauna was thought to have been present from the first creation of life, perhaps in the mind of God. That idea or plan had provided the direction and the guiding force to the entire evolutionary process.
For many men the abolition of that teleological kind of evolution was the most significant and least palatable of Darwin’s suggestions. The Origin of Species recognized no goal set either by God or nature.
Thomas Kuhn in The Structure of Scientific Revolutions
This is an interesting historical note, but I am having a hard time seeing why it is a rationality quote. Perhaps as a record of people acting irrationally? Would you mind explaining a bit?
There a public misconception about Darwin having been primarily opposed for advocating evolution when that wasn’t his biggest problem.
Today there are some people who think of themselves as Darwinists but who follow teleological notions of evolution and say things like: “The goal of life is to procreate.”
The controversial thing that Darwin said was that there’s no goal.
Thomas Kuhn in The Structure of Scientific Revolutions
This is an interesting historical note, but I am having a hard time seeing why it is a rationality quote. Perhaps as a record of people acting irrationally? Would you mind explaining a bit?
There a public misconception about Darwin having been primarily opposed for advocating evolution when that wasn’t his biggest problem.
Today there are some people who think of themselves as Darwinists but who follow teleological notions of evolution and say things like: “The goal of life is to procreate.”
The controversial thing that Darwin said was that there’s no goal.