Dreams don’t suddenly become real only after you wake up. That’s utterly absurd. I know for a fact I am conscious while I am dreaming—it’s not just a bunch of memories I can only access later. I’m frankly flabbergasted that you believe otherwise.
When I imagine a non-self-aware entity perceiving colors, I imagine that the part of their brain involved in sensory processing is… doing the sensory processing! There is something which it is like to have a temporal lobe analyzing data filtered through the retina, regardless of what else is in your brain! You can’t just be doing complex computations like that without experiencing them.
And by the way, when I close my eyes, I can still see. There might not be much to look at, but my visual processing still works. That part of your response was badly worded.
Your “planner” seems like a confused, pseudo-physicalized version of a soul to me. You haven’t actually solved the problem of how qualia arise in the first place, you’ve just shoved it into a corner of the brain and claimed to dissolve the problem. Okay, so suppose you’re right and only the planner part of the brain has qualia, and qualia exist only because of it—but what are they? We both know there is, in fact a difference between qualia and basically everything else in the universe. You can’t solve the hard problem by saying “aha, the brain doesn’t do it, a specific part of the brain does it!”
Meanwhile, if you believe as I do that qualia are just what computations of all kinds “look like from the inside”, the problem actually does dissolve. If you haven’t looked into integrated information theory, I would suggest you do so: I think they are somehow incorrect as their theory makes a few unintuitive predictions, but it’s the closest to what I think of as a reasonable theory of consciousness that I’ve ever seen.
Dreams don’t suddenly become real only after you wake up. That’s utterly absurd. I know for a fact I am conscious while I am dreaming—it’s not just a bunch of memories I can only access later. I’m frankly flabbergasted that you believe otherwise.
When I imagine a non-self-aware entity perceiving colors, I imagine that the part of their brain involved in sensory processing is… doing the sensory processing! There is something which it is like to have a temporal lobe analyzing data filtered through the retina, regardless of what else is in your brain! You can’t just be doing complex computations like that without experiencing them.
And by the way, when I close my eyes, I can still see. There might not be much to look at, but my visual processing still works. That part of your response was badly worded.
Your “planner” seems like a confused, pseudo-physicalized version of a soul to me. You haven’t actually solved the problem of how qualia arise in the first place, you’ve just shoved it into a corner of the brain and claimed to dissolve the problem. Okay, so suppose you’re right and only the planner part of the brain has qualia, and qualia exist only because of it—but what are they? We both know there is, in fact a difference between qualia and basically everything else in the universe. You can’t solve the hard problem by saying “aha, the brain doesn’t do it, a specific part of the brain does it!”
Meanwhile, if you believe as I do that qualia are just what computations of all kinds “look like from the inside”, the problem actually does dissolve. If you haven’t looked into integrated information theory, I would suggest you do so: I think they are somehow incorrect as their theory makes a few unintuitive predictions, but it’s the closest to what I think of as a reasonable theory of consciousness that I’ve ever seen.