Yeah. Another problem is that the last few chapters of HPMOR have been kinda “wobbly”, like the last chapters of Ra. Oh we’re saved, oh no we’re doomed again, etc.
It seems to me that many people expect HPMOR to be better than it actually is. To me, the fic has always felt like it’s promising slightly more than it can deliver, though it’s still very enjoyable to read. The characters and their changing points of view are wonderfully realized, e.g. Dumbledore is built up as someone who does amazing clever stuff offscreen. But the actual plotlines of the fic are, and always were, a bit weaker than what the characters suggest. The riff on Ender’s Game, the improbable escapes in Azkaban, the whole SPHEW thing (seriously?), and now the mirror.
I propose that we enjoy the fic for what it does well, and stop demanding so much in terms of plot. If you want a really good plot, the obvious solution is to make one up yourself :-)
If you want a really good plot, the obvious solution is to make one up yourself :-)
While I agree with the sentiment expressed here, I think that might be easier said than done. After all, it’s easy to criticize a dish, much harder to make a better one.
Yeah. Another problem is that the last few chapters of HPMOR have been kinda “wobbly”, like the last chapters of Ra. Oh we’re saved, oh no we’re doomed again, etc.
It seems to me that many people expect HPMOR to be better than it actually is. To me, the fic has always felt like it’s promising slightly more than it can deliver, though it’s still very enjoyable to read. The characters and their changing points of view are wonderfully realized, e.g. Dumbledore is built up as someone who does amazing clever stuff offscreen. But the actual plotlines of the fic are, and always were, a bit weaker than what the characters suggest. The riff on Ender’s Game, the improbable escapes in Azkaban, the whole SPHEW thing (seriously?), and now the mirror.
I propose that we enjoy the fic for what it does well, and stop demanding so much in terms of plot. If you want a really good plot, the obvious solution is to make one up yourself :-)
While I agree with the sentiment expressed here, I think that might be easier said than done. After all, it’s easy to criticize a dish, much harder to make a better one.