No substantial disagreement with most of your comment. I will just note that most of your points (which do show that I was being overly optimistic) don’t as a whole substantially undermine the basic point being made about Eliezer’s claim.
I think your point about small fields being able to do damage is an interesting one (and one I’ve never seen before) and raises all sorts of issues that I’ll need to think about.
No substantial disagreement with most of your comment. I will just note that most of your points (which do show that I was being overly optimistic) don’t as a whole substantially undermine the basic point being made about Eliezer’s claim.
I think your point about small fields being able to do damage is an interesting one (and one I’ve never seen before) and raises all sorts of issues that I’ll need to think about.