If this were true how would anyone ever get the first citation?
Zed didn’t say you should never cite a previously uncited paper, only that you shouldn’t invest time and effort into work that depends on the assumption that its conclusions are sound. There are many possible reasons why you might nevertheless want to cite it, and perhaps even give it some lip service.
Zed didn’t say you should never cite a previously uncited paper, only that you shouldn’t invest time and effort into work that depends on the assumption that its conclusions are sound. There are many possible reasons why you might nevertheless want to cite it, and perhaps even give it some lip service.
Especially if it’s your own.
Self-citations are usually counted separately (both for formal purposes and in informal assessments of this sort).