Japan is different from the USA and Europe because they have two sartorial lineages: a native one and a Western one. While it’s not possible to counter-signal with a suit in Japan, I feel the equivalent would be to wear traditional clothing like a samue or jinbei, which have their own set of challenges.
That Onion article is savage. It’s hard to imagine any culture and circumstance where wearing a business suit ironically would work. That said, I did successfully wear a suit ironically once. It was part of a running joke someone else started.
While it’s not possible to counter-signal with a suit in Japan, I feel the equivalent would be to wear traditional clothing like a samue or jinbei, which have their own set of challenges.
Yep. It can be pretty funny watching the contexts in which you can get away with a happi coat or a kimono/yukata; I can only speak from Japanese media rather than personal experience, but one thing I’ve noticed is that it seems a non-retired man wearing a kimono can still get away with it today as long as they are a sufficiently accomplished humanist or literary scholar (but not STEM). It reminds me of the ‘tweed jacket’ professor archetype here: you can still get away with wearing a tweed jacket with leather patches etc, but you’d better be a professor or a novelist or something of that ilk if you don’t want to be quietly judged for it.
Japan is different from the USA and Europe because they have two sartorial lineages: a native one and a Western one. While it’s not possible to counter-signal with a suit in Japan, I feel the equivalent would be to wear traditional clothing like a samue or jinbei, which have their own set of challenges.
That Onion article is savage. It’s hard to imagine any culture and circumstance where wearing a business suit ironically would work. That said, I did successfully wear a suit ironically once. It was part of a running joke someone else started.
Yep. It can be pretty funny watching the contexts in which you can get away with a happi coat or a kimono/yukata; I can only speak from Japanese media rather than personal experience, but one thing I’ve noticed is that it seems a non-retired man wearing a kimono can still get away with it today as long as they are a sufficiently accomplished humanist or literary scholar (but not STEM). It reminds me of the ‘tweed jacket’ professor archetype here: you can still get away with wearing a tweed jacket with leather patches etc, but you’d better be a professor or a novelist or something of that ilk if you don’t want to be quietly judged for it.
Another option is to go full Victorian, with coattails and a top hat.