Deep Learning systems don’t look like they FOOM. Stochastic Gradient Descent doesn’t look like it will treacherous turn.
I think you’ve updated incorrectly, by failing to keep track of what the advance predictions were (or would have been) about when a FOOM or a treacherous turn will happen.
If foom happens, it happens no earlier than the point where AI systems can do software-development on their own codebases, without relying on close collaboration with a skilled human programmer. This point has not yet been reached; they’re idiot-savants with skill gaps that prevent them from working independently, and no AI system has passed the litmus test I use for identifying good (human) programmers. They’re advancing in that direction pretty rapidly, but they’re unambiguously not there yet.
Similarly, if a treacherous turn happens, it happens no earlier than the point where AI systems can do strategic reasoning with long chains of inference; this again has an idiot-savant dynamic going on, which can create the false impression that this landmark has been reached, when in fact it hasn’t.
I think you’ve updated incorrectly, by failing to keep track of what the advance predictions were (or would have been) about when a FOOM or a treacherous turn will happen.
If foom happens, it happens no earlier than the point where AI systems can do software-development on their own codebases, without relying on close collaboration with a skilled human programmer. This point has not yet been reached; they’re idiot-savants with skill gaps that prevent them from working independently, and no AI system has passed the litmus test I use for identifying good (human) programmers. They’re advancing in that direction pretty rapidly, but they’re unambiguously not there yet.
Similarly, if a treacherous turn happens, it happens no earlier than the point where AI systems can do strategic reasoning with long chains of inference; this again has an idiot-savant dynamic going on, which can create the false impression that this landmark has been reached, when in fact it hasn’t.