I pictured a basically decent guy with a job, making little money, justifiably resentful of a system where his work doesn’t make him much better off than people who don’t work at all, who aims some of that resentment at the first guy, who I took to be not working in distinction. I don’t think his generalization about the poor was meant to be absolute, and don’t think it necessary for him to qualify his statement with somebutnotall.
The one line description leaves a lot open to the imagination. But I picture the salts of the earth a bit tidier than this guy. I’d call him the salty of the earth.
What I’d picture the salt of the earth guy saying is that “The government should make sure families have enough to live on, but not so much that they don’t want to work to make more.”
I had some of that reaction too.
I pictured a basically decent guy with a job, making little money, justifiably resentful of a system where his work doesn’t make him much better off than people who don’t work at all, who aims some of that resentment at the first guy, who I took to be not working in distinction. I don’t think his generalization about the poor was meant to be absolute, and don’t think it necessary for him to qualify his statement with somebutnotall.
The one line description leaves a lot open to the imagination. But I picture the salts of the earth a bit tidier than this guy. I’d call him the salty of the earth.
What I’d picture the salt of the earth guy saying is that “The government should make sure families have enough to live on, but not so much that they don’t want to work to make more.”