[I’m deleting this comment soon. No reason to pick another fight. Maybe I’ll take Morendil’s advice and write a post about how much I disagree with people assuming moral positions for anyone but themselves and where I see that heading. I don’t have time at the moment.]
I urge you to err strongly on the side of not deleting comments. If I post something I later regret, I just edit them to say “oops!” For one thing, it’s easy to overreact and underestimate their quality.
Disagree that we should discuss what people values should be in this post or anywhere on Less Wrong. This is a place about rationality right? NOT MORALIZING.
I’m not willing for this be a place where we discuss what moral judgments are appropriate or not.
We have had numerous top-level posts regarding ethics and meta-ethics; what one should do seems intimately related to rationality. This is already a place where we discuss what moral judgements are correct, and has been since its inception. Example
[I’m deleting this comment soon. No reason to pick another fight. Maybe I’ll take Morendil’s advice and write a post about how much I disagree with people assuming moral positions for anyone but themselves and where I see that heading. I don’t have time at the moment.]
I urge you to err strongly on the side of not deleting comments. If I post something I later regret, I just edit them to say “oops!” For one thing, it’s easy to overreact and underestimate their quality.
OK.* I was mainly just trying to prevent another big long sidetrack. Since thomblake already replied, it needs to stay anyway.
*From now on, I’ll just edit with an ‘oops’.
We have had numerous top-level posts regarding ethics and meta-ethics; what one should do seems intimately related to rationality. This is already a place where we discuss what moral judgements are correct, and has been since its inception. Example