It was only partly intended to be snarky, there was also a genuine question intended. It’s not clear to me whether the 800,000 is particularly important to you. You could somewhat reasonably claim that you would still consider this a very serious issue even if only 1⁄10 as many people were actually affected.
I don’t know where the cutoff is. The articles you linked downgraded my concern about the topic, or rather, increased my error bars to the point where I no longer feel comfortable placing it in any particular category.
I know that I regularly mock news reports if they mention fewer than 100 deaths and costs in the billions to solve/prevent in the same segment, the most recent example being the Toyota recalls. I expect I’m doing lazy cost-utility analysis.
Would you change your opinion if it turned out that the figures for the number of victims are grossly exaggerated?
Would you update on new evidence? Are you a bayessian? Do you read LessWrong?
The 600,000 to 800,000 figure is cited from a 2005 report; mattnewport’s articles are from 2007.
I was attempting to agree with him in the same snarky format he was using. I could have just said, “Yes.”
It was only partly intended to be snarky, there was also a genuine question intended. It’s not clear to me whether the 800,000 is particularly important to you. You could somewhat reasonably claim that you would still consider this a very serious issue even if only 1⁄10 as many people were actually affected.
I don’t know where the cutoff is. The articles you linked downgraded my concern about the topic, or rather, increased my error bars to the point where I no longer feel comfortable placing it in any particular category.
I know that I regularly mock news reports if they mention fewer than 100 deaths and costs in the billions to solve/prevent in the same segment, the most recent example being the Toyota recalls. I expect I’m doing lazy cost-utility analysis.
I apologize—I’m not good at picking up sarcasm in text.
(I value the impetus to look it up myself, however, so I don’t mind.)