Really!? Okay, I’ll have to really present the argument when I write that post.
I do agree with your logic for why opponents misunderstanding the argument would make people sure they’re right, by general association. It’s a separate factor from the irritation, so I think I mis-statedit as a subset (although part of it seems to be; it’s irritating to have people repeatedly mis-characterize your position).
It seems pretty apparent to me when I watch people have discussions/arguments that their irritation/anger makes them dig in on their position. It seems to follow from evolutionary psychology: if you make me angry, my brain reacts like we’re in a fight. I now want to win that fight, so I need to prove you wrong. Believing any of your arguments or understating mine would lead to losing the fight I feel I’m in.
This isn’t usually how motivated reasoning is discussed, so I guess it does really take some careful explanation. It seems intuitive and obvious to me after holding this theory for years, but that could be my own motivated reasoning...
Really!? Okay, I’ll have to really present the argument when I write that post.
I do agree with your logic for why opponents misunderstanding the argument would make people sure they’re right, by general association. It’s a separate factor from the irritation, so I think I mis-statedit as a subset (although part of it seems to be; it’s irritating to have people repeatedly mis-characterize your position).
It seems pretty apparent to me when I watch people have discussions/arguments that their irritation/anger makes them dig in on their position. It seems to follow from evolutionary psychology: if you make me angry, my brain reacts like we’re in a fight. I now want to win that fight, so I need to prove you wrong. Believing any of your arguments or understating mine would lead to losing the fight I feel I’m in.
This isn’t usually how motivated reasoning is discussed, so I guess it does really take some careful explanation. It seems intuitive and obvious to me after holding this theory for years, but that could be my own motivated reasoning...