True, my use of “stupid” and “reasonable” may have been a bit careless, my main point wasn’t that believing that was stupid, but rather that one shouldn’t pay too much attention to stupid arguments—in this context, MixedNuts was saying that feminist claimed X, though none in the thread who seem to identify as feminists agree with X.
But I still think that dressing in a “sexy” way does increase the chances of catcalling (for rape, probably too, but that covers a wider range of things than catcalling does). I’m not aware of any rigorous studies (your link seems like weak evidence in that favor, and most anecdotes in this thread and outside are in the same direction).
(I agree with the core of your criticism; even if my main point wasn’t about stupidity in practice I was still sneaking in connotations)
True, my use of “stupid” and “reasonable” may have been a bit careless, my main point wasn’t that believing that was stupid, but rather that one shouldn’t pay too much attention to stupid arguments—in this context, MixedNuts was saying that feminist claimed X, though none in the thread who seem to identify as feminists agree with X.
But I still think that dressing in a “sexy” way does increase the chances of catcalling (for rape, probably too, but that covers a wider range of things than catcalling does). I’m not aware of any rigorous studies (your link seems like weak evidence in that favor, and most anecdotes in this thread and outside are in the same direction).
(I agree with the core of your criticism; even if my main point wasn’t about stupidity in practice I was still sneaking in connotations)