I think the point of the Star Wars anecdote is: Woman do engage in roleplaying but when they do they don’t focus on papers-and-dice fighting and instead have a discussion about moral issues.
Is that actually true, though ? This seems to fit the pattern of “men are combative, women are nurturing”, which is often denounced as a stereotype; at the very least, there is a lot of debate on whether or not this principle is generally applicable.
I’m not saying that the statement is wrong, necessarily; only that I require more evidence to be convinced.
This seems to fit the pattern of “men are combative, women are nurturing”,
I would read it more as “men like to model situations, women like to model people.” This may be a stereotype, but I’ve noticed it to be anecdotally true. Men, when spending time together socially, tend to talk more about sports and politics than women do; women spend more time talking about other people (i.e. gossip) and analyzing their motivations. Fighting elves is a situation; you don’t have to try to understand the elves’ motivations and ‘drama’ in order to fight them.
“This may be a stereotype, but I’ve noticed it to be anecdotally true.”
“but”
What do you think sterotypes are? Generally they tend to be statements that are true 30-90% of the time, which should provide plenty of room for confirming annecdotes.
Is that actually true, though ? This seems to fit the pattern of “men are combative, women are nurturing”, which is often denounced as a stereotype; at the very least, there is a lot of debate on whether or not this principle is generally applicable.
I’m not saying that the statement is wrong, necessarily; only that I require more evidence to be convinced.
I would read it more as “men like to model situations, women like to model people.” This may be a stereotype, but I’ve noticed it to be anecdotally true. Men, when spending time together socially, tend to talk more about sports and politics than women do; women spend more time talking about other people (i.e. gossip) and analyzing their motivations. Fighting elves is a situation; you don’t have to try to understand the elves’ motivations and ‘drama’ in order to fight them.
“This may be a stereotype, but I’ve noticed it to be anecdotally true.” “but” What do you think sterotypes are? Generally they tend to be statements that are true 30-90% of the time, which should provide plenty of room for confirming annecdotes.