Hm. It seems entirely fine to me to have it be unpossible for logged-out users and newly created accounts to comment, but I think I’d prefer to have it readable by e.g. my FB audience who aren’t LWers?
Else if you prefer I could shift this over to Medium.
Chatted with Ray and seems okay to make it generally readable again. I will do that.
Restricting comments does seem like a good option, though we’d have to create the option for that.
I think this is a really good post and considered even “frontpage but hidden from new users” since I think this does have timeless Rationality content.
My thought was: If this post anonymized the people-in-question, I’d feel pretty fine about it being frontpaged (without any special hidden-ness). I do think that’d also make it a worse post in some ways – the concrete examples are helpful, and the evidence you’ve specifically cited (pretty hard to anonymize), helps show what the process of evaluation is like.
Avoid attracting unwanted internet debate… reconsider[ing] the risk.
It seems entirely fine to me… if you prefer I could shift this over to Medium.
Seems like a good opportunity to practice murphyjutsu, which I just learned about just now and I really like it so I’m going to practice it to keep it cognitively available.
Hm. It seems entirely fine to me to have it be unpossible for logged-out users and newly created accounts to comment, but I think I’d prefer to have it readable by e.g. my FB audience who aren’t LWers?
Else if you prefer I could shift this over to Medium.
Chatted with Ray and seems okay to make it generally readable again. I will do that.
Restricting comments does seem like a good option, though we’d have to create the option for that.
I think this is a really good post and considered even “frontpage but hidden from new users” since I think this does have timeless Rationality content.
My thought was: If this post anonymized the people-in-question, I’d feel pretty fine about it being frontpaged (without any special hidden-ness). I do think that’d also make it a worse post in some ways – the concrete examples are helpful, and the evidence you’ve specifically cited (pretty hard to anonymize), helps show what the process of evaluation is like.
Seems like a good opportunity to practice murphyjutsu, which I just learned about just now and I really like it so I’m going to practice it to keep it cognitively available.