As I understand it, ecological psychology is more of a framework for the interpretation of existing results than a theory, but it does make predictions about coaching interventions, and yeah it seems like the results are pretty robust
Yeah—as far as I know, ecological psychology is less about messing with undergrads in the lab and more about understanding how the constraints of the body and environment inform and enable what were historically thought to be “purely mental” activities. The empirical usefulness of ecological psychology is evident in how ideas from it helps us build robots that walk and grasp and so on.
There’s quite a lot to say about this, of course. I’d be willing to write some posts about it, but I don’t have a lot of time I’m able to commit to doing so, and I think it would take a lot of work. But it’d be interesting, so we’ll see.
Does it replicate?
As I understand it, ecological psychology is more of a framework for the interpretation of existing results than a theory, but it does make predictions about coaching interventions, and yeah it seems like the results are pretty robust
Here is a compilation of studies comparing approaches favored by ecologically-minded coaches to more traditional training interventions: https://perceptionaction.com/comparative/
Could be biased of course, but it may be a good starting point
Yeah—as far as I know, ecological psychology is less about messing with undergrads in the lab and more about understanding how the constraints of the body and environment inform and enable what were historically thought to be “purely mental” activities. The empirical usefulness of ecological psychology is evident in how ideas from it helps us build robots that walk and grasp and so on.
Could you say more about this?
Yes—didn’t see this comment. Basically, researchers have found ways to build robots that move like people, and ecological psychology is the framework that best helps us understand how to make sense of this in terms of what the brain does. Here’s an example.
There’s quite a lot to say about this, of course. I’d be willing to write some posts about it, but I don’t have a lot of time I’m able to commit to doing so, and I think it would take a lot of work. But it’d be interesting, so we’ll see.