There are plenty of times where someone writes a LessWrong post and while I do agree with the central point of the post I disagree with a noncentral part of the post.
A person might use some historical example and I disagree with the example. In those cases it’s for me an open question whether or not it’s useful to write the comment that disagrees or whether that’s bad for LW. It might be bad because people feel like they are getting noncentral feedback and that discourages them.
There are plenty of times where someone writes a LessWrong post and while I do agree with the central point of the post I disagree with a noncentral part of the post.
A person might use some historical example and I disagree with the example. In those cases it’s for me an open question whether or not it’s useful to write the comment that disagrees or whether that’s bad for LW. It might be bad because people feel like they are getting noncentral feedback and that discourages them.