Do we just ignore Neoclassical works? Or does that not count as ‘classical’?
On the contrary the definition (from wikipedia) that you are responding to seems to go out if its way to ensure that they would be included (to the extent that the pieces did, in fact, conform to the same style.)
Europe before WWI produced classical music so good that no one has been able to compete with it (for classical music, not music in general) since then.
I don’t have any particular opinion on the subject. Classical music is ok in moderation and I’ll play it myself from time to time (trumpet). But I have absolutely no interest in identifying which pieces belong to which area and how they are ranked by those who consider themselves experts.
After all, anyone with decent taste will tell you that the best classical music has less aesthetic merit than the best Weird Al songs.
I’m not sure I know how to cash out “aesthetic merit”, but seeing Al play Yoda live, and in particular seeing him and Jim West duet on accordian and guitar, is a moment of joy unsurpassed by any I’ve experienced at classical performances.
Do we just ignore Neoclassical works? Or does that not count as ‘classical’?
The real reason we don’t produce classical music like that anymore is arguably because we produce way better music now.
On the contrary the definition (from wikipedia) that you are responding to seems to go out if its way to ensure that they would be included (to the extent that the pieces did, in fact, conform to the same style.)
Oh well then NancyLebovitz’s line:
is not correct.
I don’t have any particular opinion on the subject. Classical music is ok in moderation and I’ll play it myself from time to time (trumpet). But I have absolutely no interest in identifying which pieces belong to which area and how they are ranked by those who consider themselves experts.
After all, anyone with decent taste will tell you that the best classical music has less aesthetic merit than the best Weird Al songs.
I’m not sure I know how to cash out “aesthetic merit”, but seeing Al play Yoda live, and in particular seeing him and Jim West duet on accordian and guitar, is a moment of joy unsurpassed by any I’ve experienced at classical performances.
I saw you advertising the live performance—almost certainly what primed him as the example. I was jealous! :)