It’s unlikely there would be end-to-end oversight. Legal organ harvesters would probably not get looked at very closely (not enough money for inspection) and could easily pass off stolen organ as legitimately bought ones.
I disagree with your characterization of pressured people as idiots. “You aren’t bringing home the bacon and you have poor marriage prospects, so you’d better sell a kidney, or I’ll kick you out of the house” is not idiocy. But that’s not really the point.
I don’t see at all how a price floor helps with that.
It’s unlikely there would be end-to-end oversight.
Why not? It’s outright illegal in every country except one. I would expect it to be heavily regulated if it is ever allowed. If there are problems with stolen organs, they would definitely start regulating it.
Also, I haven’t seen anything saying that this is a problem in Iran. I read it has been a problem in India, so they made it illegal. It’s not the same as regulating, but it shows that they won’t allow that sort of thing to happen.
I disagree with your characterization of pressured people as idiots.
I just mean people selling their kidneys when it hurts them. “Idiots” meaning acting irrationally, not necessarily stupider than average.
I guess it’s possible for it to happen like you describe so that they have an additional incentive to sell, in a bad way. I don’t think that’s likely to happen.
I don’t see at all how a price floor helps with that.
It makes it more likely that it actually will be worth while for them. If it’s never worth while to sell your kidney for below $x, then setting a price floor above $x would at least mean that some of the people selling their kidneys would benefit.
It’s unlikely there would be end-to-end oversight. Legal organ harvesters would probably not get looked at very closely (not enough money for inspection) and could easily pass off stolen organ as legitimately bought ones.
I disagree with your characterization of pressured people as idiots. “You aren’t bringing home the bacon and you have poor marriage prospects, so you’d better sell a kidney, or I’ll kick you out of the house” is not idiocy. But that’s not really the point.
I don’t see at all how a price floor helps with that.
Why not? It’s outright illegal in every country except one. I would expect it to be heavily regulated if it is ever allowed. If there are problems with stolen organs, they would definitely start regulating it.
Also, I haven’t seen anything saying that this is a problem in Iran. I read it has been a problem in India, so they made it illegal. It’s not the same as regulating, but it shows that they won’t allow that sort of thing to happen.
I just mean people selling their kidneys when it hurts them. “Idiots” meaning acting irrationally, not necessarily stupider than average.
I guess it’s possible for it to happen like you describe so that they have an additional incentive to sell, in a bad way. I don’t think that’s likely to happen.
It makes it more likely that it actually will be worth while for them. If it’s never worth while to sell your kidney for below $x, then setting a price floor above $x would at least mean that some of the people selling their kidneys would benefit.
So tax organ sales enough to pay for the inspection costs.