I like the wide variety of possible reactions available in Slack and Discord, though I think for LW, the default / starting set could be a bit smaller, to reduce complexity / overwhelming-ness of picking an appropriate reaction.
Reactions I’d strike:
Additional questions (I’d feel a bit disconcerted if I received this reaction without an accompanying comment.)
Strawman (kinda harsh for a reaction)
Concrete (this is either covered by an upvote, or seems like faint praise if not accompanied by an upvote.)
one of “key insight” or “insightful” and one of “too harsh” or “combative” (too much overlap)
But maybe it’s easier to wait and see which reactions are used least often, and then eliminate those.
I like the wide variety of possible reactions available in Slack and Discord, though I think for LW, the default / starting set could be a bit smaller, to reduce complexity / overwhelming-ness of picking an appropriate reaction.
Reactions I’d strike:
Additional questions (I’d feel a bit disconcerted if I received this reaction without an accompanying comment.)
Strawman (kinda harsh for a reaction)
Concrete (this is either covered by an upvote, or seems like faint praise if not accompanied by an upvote.)
one of “key insight” or “insightful” and one of “too harsh” or “combative” (too much overlap)
But maybe it’s easier to wait and see which reactions are used least often, and then eliminate those.