Ok, I should probably wait a bit before making this recommendation, but I currently think this is a nice addition, which should REPLACE agree/disagree, rather than being yet another mechanism for low-effort feedback. Don’t overcomplicate it with different placement or fancy anti-reactions, just put a straightforward reaction display and selector where the agreement buttons are today.
I’m tempted to recommend that it replace Karma as well, but that’s more baked into the site and would be trickier.
Even if it is “both” I think next to the votes/agreement is the right place for the reacts. Quick paint mess around:
Looks clean to me, although maybe for people on phones with smaller screens it will make problems. (I am on a desktop with a big screen where considerations will be different).
Ok, I should probably wait a bit before making this recommendation, but I currently think this is a nice addition, which should REPLACE agree/disagree, rather than being yet another mechanism for low-effort feedback. Don’t overcomplicate it with different placement or fancy anti-reactions, just put a straightforward reaction display and selector where the agreement buttons are today.
I’m tempted to recommend that it replace Karma as well, but that’s more baked into the site and would be trickier.
Even if it is “both” I think next to the votes/agreement is the right place for the reacts. Quick paint mess around:
Looks clean to me, although maybe for people on phones with smaller screens it will make problems. (I am on a desktop with a big screen where considerations will be different).
I agree to the redundancy with the agree/disagree.