I’ve been thinking about this problem for several years now, and others much longer. Suzanne cited none of their thoughts or ideas—and the content of her presentation strongly suggested that she was not aware of most of them.
I’m sure Suzanne’s input will be welcomed, but at the moment it is pretty obvious that she really needs to first do some research.
My take on it is that this post at Physics and Cake was simply a follow-up post to her talk at H+, which was itself also a forum intended for a broader audience within minimal time for any introductions of background material (which, from discussions with Suzanne, I know she is aware of). I would like to repeat that you should not rush to conclusions, but instead stay tuned.
I’ve been thinking about this problem for several years now, and others much longer. Suzanne cited none of their thoughts or ideas—and the content of her presentation strongly suggested that she was not aware of most of them.
I’m sure Suzanne’s input will be welcomed, but at the moment it is pretty obvious that she really needs to first do some research.
My take on it is that this post at Physics and Cake was simply a follow-up post to her talk at H+, which was itself also a forum intended for a broader audience within minimal time for any introductions of background material (which, from discussions with Suzanne, I know she is aware of). I would like to repeat that you should not rush to conclusions, but instead stay tuned.