Well, I’m being a little postmodern, but how often have you heard people refer to themselves? Not quite ‘i told you so’ but in a similar vein. Pundits do this a lot. “well if you recall, last year I said xy&z, and look what happened?”.
It’s the falacy related to the fact that, of all the possible outcomes, at least ONE person will probably be right. But, that fact is purely casual/trivial.
I just found it poetic that one of the rules of the thread is ‘do not quote yourself’… Clearly that’s an issue that not all people recognize.
“Like any dogma, it is honored far more in the breach than in the observance.”
As is appropriate when the dogma in question is trivially observed yet distracting when breached. I would expect dogma to be encouraged with honor for observance more when the reverse is the case. For example, when a dogma pertains to a particularly noble or self sacrificial action that is far rarer than the ‘null’ breach.
If we were to have designated threads for self-quoting, I would imagine there would have to be some effective restrictions to keep the quality high—I would imagine a time limit that would have to expire, for example.
not trying to be glib here, but:
“• Do not quote yourself.” −4wnoise
...what?
Well, I’m being a little postmodern, but how often have you heard people refer to themselves? Not quite ‘i told you so’ but in a similar vein. Pundits do this a lot. “well if you recall, last year I said xy&z, and look what happened?”. It’s the falacy related to the fact that, of all the possible outcomes, at least ONE person will probably be right. But, that fact is purely casual/trivial. I just found it poetic that one of the rules of the thread is ‘do not quote yourself’… Clearly that’s an issue that not all people recognize.
That is insightful and all, but now falls under:
;)
fair enough. Rats.
“Like any dogma, it is honored far more in the breach than in the observance.”
-Benoit Mandelbrot
As is appropriate when the dogma in question is trivially observed yet distracting when breached. I would expect dogma to be encouraged with honor for observance more when the reverse is the case. For example, when a dogma pertains to a particularly noble or self sacrificial action that is far rarer than the ‘null’ breach.
If we were to have designated threads for self-quoting, I would imagine there would have to be some effective restrictions to keep the quality high—I would imagine a time limit that would have to expire, for example.