Why do you want to put a label on their belief? There are some adverse effects like they can get offended, or being a Toolboxist becomes a part of their identity and then it’s even harder to change their mind.
It helps withdraw from the conversation. You believe in <belief> and I believe in One-Magisterium Bayes is a script that people use to abandon disagreements. Like saying “You are a Muslim and I am a Christian, so we should change topics”.
Why do you want to put a label on their belief? There are some adverse effects like they can get offended, or being a Toolboxist becomes a part of their identity and then it’s even harder to change their mind.
It helps withdraw from the conversation. You believe in <belief> and I believe in One-Magisterium Bayes is a script that people use to abandon disagreements. Like saying “You are a Muslim and I am a Christian, so we should change topics”.