I don’t think so. I’m a processist (though I do think it’s unlikely that quantum effects matter), but I can imagine kinds of discoveries that would falsify my current belief on that matter. It could turn out, once we localize and understand consciousness:
...that it’s not even “on” or merely suspended all the time, but sometimes is “off” in the normal course of brain operation.
...that it’s possible to erase clear memories even with the brain in the same physical state (this would support either Porter’s view or some more spiritual dualism).
...that there is more than a single thread of consciousness, and no particular continuity of identity for the person as a whole, even though some thread is operating all the time.
Of those, one and three even seem plausible, but I can’t think of a way to do the experiments at our current level of understanding and technology. In any case, once we actually have a working and well-tested theory of consciousness, identity will either vanish or be similarly well-understood.
I don’t think so. I’m a processist (though I do think it’s unlikely that quantum effects matter), but I can imagine kinds of discoveries that would falsify my current belief on that matter. It could turn out, once we localize and understand consciousness:
...that it’s not even “on” or merely suspended all the time, but sometimes is “off” in the normal course of brain operation.
...that it’s possible to erase clear memories even with the brain in the same physical state (this would support either Porter’s view or some more spiritual dualism).
...that there is more than a single thread of consciousness, and no particular continuity of identity for the person as a whole, even though some thread is operating all the time.
Of those, one and three even seem plausible, but I can’t think of a way to do the experiments at our current level of understanding and technology. In any case, once we actually have a working and well-tested theory of consciousness, identity will either vanish or be similarly well-understood.