“Upvoted because it’s relevant and perhaps important, but the premises are too far from both my intuitions and reasoned beliefs (which I acknowledge are deeply entwined with intuitions, and not necessarily “truth”) for me to participate. I look forward to seeing the conversation. ”
I’m not sure what the emoticon or short phrase for that looks like. perhaps thumbs-up+shrug.
FYI I think that’s a complex enough sentiment that just making the comment is fine (and in a React world, once you’ve made that comment, anyone with similar responses can say ‘agree’ to your comment).
Possible shorthand might be something like “Interested in seeing the discussion” (which I expect to be commonly used for topics that seem important but require domain expertise to contribute meaningfully)
Here’s a challenge: I was about to make this (low-value) comment on: https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/cnBGXGSFGpfvknFc3/ramifications-of-limited-positive-value-unlimited-negative-1
“Upvoted because it’s relevant and perhaps important, but the premises are too far from both my intuitions and reasoned beliefs (which I acknowledge are deeply entwined with intuitions, and not necessarily “truth”) for me to participate. I look forward to seeing the conversation. ”
I’m not sure what the emoticon or short phrase for that looks like. perhaps thumbs-up+shrug.
FYI I think that’s a complex enough sentiment that just making the comment is fine (and in a React world, once you’ve made that comment, anyone with similar responses can say ‘agree’ to your comment).
Possible shorthand might be something like “Interested in seeing the discussion” (which I expect to be commonly used for topics that seem important but require domain expertise to contribute meaningfully)