I think that your position on destructive uploads doesn’t make sense, and you did a great job of showing why with your thought experiment.
The fact that you can transition yourself over time to the machine, and you still consider it ‘you’, and you cant actually tell at what specific line you crossed in order to become a ‘machine’, means that your original state (human brain) and final state (upload) are essentially the same.
I don’t like the structure of this argument. If I morph into a coffee table, I can’t mark a specific line at which I become a piece of furniture. This doesn’t imply that I’m essentially a coffee table. No hard boundary does not imply no transition.
Error isn’t implying that the final state is different. Just that the destructive copy process is a form of death and the wired brain process isn’t.
I get where he is coming from, a copy is distinct from the original and can have different experiences. In the destructive copy scenario a person is killed and a person is born, In the wired brain scenario the person is not copied they merely change over time and nobody dies.
My view is that if I die to make a upload (which is identical to me except for greater intelligence & other benefits) then I think the gain outweighs the loss.
I think that your position on destructive uploads doesn’t make sense, and you did a great job of showing why with your thought experiment.
The fact that you can transition yourself over time to the machine, and you still consider it ‘you’, and you cant actually tell at what specific line you crossed in order to become a ‘machine’, means that your original state (human brain) and final state (upload) are essentially the same.
I don’t like the structure of this argument. If I morph into a coffee table, I can’t mark a specific line at which I become a piece of furniture. This doesn’t imply that I’m essentially a coffee table. No hard boundary does not imply no transition.
Error isn’t implying that the final state is different. Just that the destructive copy process is a form of death and the wired brain process isn’t.
I get where he is coming from, a copy is distinct from the original and can have different experiences. In the destructive copy scenario a person is killed and a person is born, In the wired brain scenario the person is not copied they merely change over time and nobody dies.
My view is that if I die to make a upload (which is identical to me except for greater intelligence & other benefits) then I think the gain outweighs the loss.