You couldn’t be expected to tell it from the grandparent, but komponisto is saying not that tonal music is bad
The title of the post is “Bad Concepts Repository”, not “Bad Musical Repertory”. Shouldn’t that make it a given that theories of things, rather than things themselves, are what what we’re critiquing here?
Hopefully you can take my
comment as an
application of the principle of charity to PhilGoetz rather than a critique of
your comment that he was responding to.
(“Harmony is a bad concept?! But all my favorite music was written using that
concept!”)
The title of the post is “Bad Concepts Repository”, not “Bad Musical Repertory”. Shouldn’t that make it a given that theories of things, rather than things themselves, are what what we’re critiquing here?
Hopefully you can take my comment as an application of the principle of charity to PhilGoetz rather than a critique of your comment that he was responding to.
(“Harmony is a bad concept?! But all my favorite music was written using that concept!”)