The outer robot, thinking about the real world, uses Aristotelian propositions referring to that world. The inner robot, thinking about the activities of the outer robot, uses propositions that are not Aristotelian in reference to the outer world; but they are still Aristotelian in its context, in reference to the thinking of the outer robot; so of course the same rules of probability theory will apply to them. The term `probability of a probability’ misses the point, since the two probabilities are at different levels.
This always seemed like a real promising idea to me. Alas, I have a day job, and it isn’t as a Prof.
The Chapter is “Inner and Outer Robots”, available here:
http://www-biba.inrialpes.fr/Jaynes/cc18i.pdf
This always seemed like a real promising idea to me. Alas, I have a day job, and it isn’t as a Prof.