I’m uncertain what you mean by the latter—the former is one case, but if you mean that the correct answer to the logic puzzle would clearly be wrong in the real world, the latter is also true. So possibly both; I was referring to a pretty broad category of poorly-considered logic puzzles.
Ah, yes, upon re-reading my wording wasn’t quite clear either.
What I was referring to is an annoying category of puzzles that require certain specific outside knowledge bits to arrive to the “correct” answer as would be marked, even though by the premises of the puzzle and the information given this is clearly a wrong answer and the desired answer isn’t even applicable to the real world in non-contrived scenarios.
In other words, a specific subset of the broad category of poorly-considered logic puzzles. Since you were referring to its parent/superset, the point is rather moot.
I’m uncertain what you mean by the latter—the former is one case, but if you mean that the correct answer to the logic puzzle would clearly be wrong in the real world, the latter is also true. So possibly both; I was referring to a pretty broad category of poorly-considered logic puzzles.
Ah, yes, upon re-reading my wording wasn’t quite clear either.
What I was referring to is an annoying category of puzzles that require certain specific outside knowledge bits to arrive to the “correct” answer as would be marked, even though by the premises of the puzzle and the information given this is clearly a wrong answer and the desired answer isn’t even applicable to the real world in non-contrived scenarios.
In other words, a specific subset of the broad category of poorly-considered logic puzzles. Since you were referring to its parent/superset, the point is rather moot.